Lecture - "Berlin"
Death no longer belongs to an individual. Acts of war and terrorism such as Hiroshima and
9/11 along with natural disasters like earth quakes and tsunamis have made mass
deaths more common. A single tombstone
could never fully express the scope of terror inflicted on the victims of these
tragedies. Architects are challenged to find
another way for their designs to speak.
Enter Peter Eisenman and Daniel Libeskind – two architects whose
architecture attempts to communicate the terrible nature of the Holocaust to
the public.
Peter Eisenman explains that “the
enormity and horror of the Holocaust are such that any attempt to represent it
by traditional means is inevitably inadequate.”
It was along these lines that he designed his Memorial to the Murdered
Jews of Europe (aka Holocaust Memorial) with 2,711 slabs on a grid pattern on a
sloping field. The slabs, which are
2.38m x .95m, vary in height from .2 to 4.8m making each slab dimensionally
unique. Eisenman intentionally created
an uneasy and confusing atmosphere so that visitors of the memorial could
relate to the Jews at the time of WWII.
Similarly, Daniel
Libeskind’s Jewish Museum of Berlin endeavors to capture the emotional journey
of the Jewish population in Germany during World War II. The Garden of Exile is connected to the
museum proper through the second tunnel which represents the mass emigration of
Jews from Germany. The garden consists
of 49 tall pillars with Russian olive trees growing on top. Similar to Eisenman’s design, the grid is on
a tilted foundation which is meant to disorient visitors and make them feel
instable.
Libeskind noted, “In my
view, architecture is a communicative medium. To me, it's a storytelling
medium. And I attempted to create a building that told that complex story in
many different ways… It's a cultural medium. It has to be able to communicate.” Archdaily describes Libeskind’s building as “less
of a museum but an experience depicting what most cannot understand,” he “translated
human experience into an architectural composition.”
Both works are meant to leave visitors feeling lost and confused like
the Jewish people so long ago who were uprooted and forced to leave their homes
or stay to die. Amongst the pillars and
slabs of both projects you can look up to the open sky and feel exalted – there
is still hope.
Eisenman avoided using symbols in his project. His field of slabs represents tombs for
victims of the mass genocide like a meadow of nameless tombstones. Libeskind’s Jewish Museum commissioned
Israeli artist, Menashe Kadishman, to exhibit Fallen Leaves in the Memory Void
of the museum, the only occupiable voided space. The exhibit consists of 10,000 punched metal
faces that he encouraged visitors to
walk on in order to hear the sounds created by the metal sheets clanging,
rattling and scraping together, an eerie, disturbing sound that would echo in
the voided space 20 meters tall and cause shivers down your spine. Libeskind pointed out that Fallen Leaves represents
“that which can never be exhibited when it comes to Jewish Berlin history:
Humanity reduced to ashes.”
Clearly, both projects bring
visitors on an emotional journey through their spaces. The architecture speaks to us about a tragedy
that very few of us could otherwise understand or identify with.
Citations:
Eisenman, Peter. "Germany's Memorial:
Memorial to the Murdered Jews of Europe, Berlin." Frontline. PBS, 31
May 2005. Web. 31 Aug. 2012. <http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/germans/memorial/eisenman.html>.
Kroll , Andrew . "AD Classics: Jewish
Museum, Berlin / Daniel Libeskind" 25 Nov 2010. ArchDaily. Accessed 31 Aug
2012. <http://www.archdaily.com/91273>.
Libeskind, Daniel, and Daniel Greene,
perf. "Daniel Libeskind - architect." Voices on Antisemitism. United
States Holocaust Memorial Museum, 13 Sep 2007. Accessed 1 Sep 2012.
<http://www.ushmm.org/museum/exhibit/focus/antisemitism/voices/transcript/?content=20070913>.
No comments:
Post a Comment